One Christmas when I was a kid, my brother decided to play a prank on our cousin Piero. Inspired by the tradition of giving coal to misbehaving children, he carefully wrapped a lump of coal as a "gift" and gave it to Piero. When Piero opened the package and saw what was inside, he burst into tears. Overwhelmed with guilt, my brother quickly handed him a real present to make up for it.
The last time I shared this story, a friend joked, "There’s no edible candy shaped like coal, is there? That would’ve softened the blow!" But as it turns out, my friend later informed me that such candy does exist—black, coal-shaped treats often sold around Christmas. Maybe my brother should’ve gone for that instead of the real thing!
This story makes me think of free allowances in the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS). Much like my brother’s attempt to soften the prank with a real gift, free allowances were designed to ease industries into carbon accountability. However, policymakers have recognized the need to phase them out for a more impactful climate strategy.
Phasing Out Free Allowances
The EU's Fit for 55 package outlines a gradual phase-out of free allowances:
- 2026: The phase-out begins.
- 2034: Free allowances are completely eliminated.
This shift aligns with the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), which ensures that imports from outside the EU face equivalent carbon costs. This approach levels the playing field while preventing "carbon leakage," where industries relocate to avoid stricter regulations.
ETS Expands Across the Globe
While the EU refines its system, emissions trading is rapidly spreading worldwide:
China runs the world’s largest ETS, focused on power generation.
South Korea, New Zealand, and California are expanding and refining their systems.
Indonesia, Mexico, and other nations are piloting programs to address emissions in key industries.
These systems aim to make carbon emissions an integral part of economic calculations, encouraging cleaner innovation and sustainability.
Rising Global Coal Demand
Despite these efforts, global coal demand continues to rise. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), coal consumption hit a record 8.7 billion tonnes in 2023 and is projected to remain at this level through 2027. This growth is largely driven by energy demands in China and India, where coal remains a dominant energy source.
This reliance on coal highlights the tension between short-term energy needs and long-term climate goals. Carbon markets, alongside investments in renewables, remain critical to balancing these competing priorities.
Final Thoughts
Just as my brother learned the importance of making amends with a real gift, the phase-out of free allowances reflects a shift toward greater accountability in carbon markets. The challenge now is to ensure these systems grow and evolve, pushing industries to innovate while addressing the urgency of climate change.
Stay Connected
If you’re as fascinated by the intersection of carbon markets, biodiversity, and the role of AI in shaping environmental solutions as I am, subscribe to my Substack. Together, we’ll dive into these critical topics—and maybe share a few lighthearted stories along the way.
Share this post